Nigeria needs to close the financial inclusion gap for women smallholder farmers

Women smallholder farmers contribute significantly to the Nigerian economy.
Shutterstock

Olayinka Adegbite, University of Pretoria; Elizabeth Mkandawire, University of Pretoria, and Lepepeule Machethe, University of Pretoria

Women smallholder farmers in Nigeria are involved in all aspects of agriculture. This ranges from producing food on farms to putting it on plates. They’re involved in planting crops, livestock production, harvesting, marketing and processing of farm produce as well as food preparation and family care.

Yet, because they are women, they are held back by unequal access to resources – especially finances – that would help make them become more successful.

Agriculture contributes significantly to Nigeria’s economy. It is also the largest employment provider, with female smallholder farmers making up almost half the number of agricultural workers. They also play an important role in aspects of sustainable development. This includes being a bulwark against hunger and poverty in rural areas. Yet the majority still struggle to access affordable financial services to help them develop their farming operations and livelihoods.

Nigeria has made progress in strengthening regulations to enhance financial inclusion. But our study found that these regulations aren’t as effective as they could be to transform agriculture.

In the study, we looked at the gender gap in access to finance among smallholder farmers in Nigeria. And the impact of this on sustainable development.

Our research showed that these women farmers tended not to have bank accounts. This meant they lacked access to financial services like savings, credit and transactions.

This gender gap needs to be closed. We propose that this be done by introducing policies that favour women farmers. This could include targets for financial inclusion. It could also include implementing policies through collaboration with public organisations, the private sector and civil society.

Including women smallholders

Financial inclusion is meant to ensure all people have equal opportunity to access and use affordable financial services. These services include savings, credits, insurance, payments, transfers and remittances.

It’s been shown to have very positive effects on the lives of poor people. In addition, financial inclusion and achieving gender equality has been shown to have a positive influence on sustainable development.

Yet, the plight of women smallholders is often ignored by policy makers, financial institutions and those working in the agricultural sector.

Our study found that a significant financial inclusion gender gap exists in Nigeria’s smallholder agriculture. The largest gender gaps were in formal account ownership and savings. In other words fewer women farmers had accounts and saved with bank financial institutions, non-bank or mobile money service providers.

Also, fewer women smallholders owned mobile phones compared to men. As mobile banking is growing in Nigeria, not having a mobile phone means that women are excluded.

Other factors contributing to women’s financial exclusion include: poverty, low levels of literacy, limited education and limited assets. In addition, because of cultural and patrilineal traditions women typically don’t own land. They also have limited decision making powers when it comes to money.

Other restrictions include the fact that most women are constrained from participation in the marketing of high value crops. And then there’s institutional discrimination. An example is when financial institutions require a male signatory to grant a formal loan to a female farmer.

Need for financial inclusion

Nigeria tabled a revised national financial inclusion strategy in 2018. It identified the need to address gender gaps in financial inclusion. But no key performance indicator was set for women in smallholder agriculture.

Our study suggests this is a major omission. Failure to address the causes of women’s financial exclusion in Nigeria’s smallholder agriculture could result in a network of negative consequences. For example, the financial inability to adopt modern technologies – or access information – increases vulnerability on a number of fronts. This includes climate change, food insecurity and malnutrition, all while the population is increasing.

In turn, this degenerates into a vicious cycle of income inequality, poverty and poor socioeconomic development. This affects not only the women smallholder farmers, but their children, households, communities and the Nigerian economy.

Recommendations

No single approach can tackle the interrelated causes and effects.

But our study identified the need for Nigeria’s strategy to integrate gender specific goals for financial inclusion in smallholder agriculture. It is also important to establish partnerships between different stakeholders. These would include government, private and non-governmental organisations that have a common interest in women smallholders’ access to finance. Such partnerships should implement and finance clear-cut strategies in bridging financial inclusion gender gaps in smallholder agriculture in Nigeria.

Approaches should include developing agricultural finance innovations that reflect the realities of women. They need to be affordable, based on the financial needs of farmers. For example financial institutions should come up with and accept options – apart from land – that can be used as collateral for women smallholder farmers.

Similarly, successful models like the Nigerian Incentive-Based Risk-Sharing System for Agricultural Lending should integrate and empower women smallholders in their agricultural value chain financing models.

Finally, it is important that Nigeria’s financial literacy agenda extend to smallholders and rural areas. And there should be systemic efforts at all level of society to ensure that women have direct access to finance and control.The Conversation

Olayinka Adegbite, PhD candidate, University of Pretoria; Elizabeth Mkandawire, Postdoctoral Fellow and Coordinator: UN Academic Impact Hub for SDG2, University of Pretoria, and Lepepeule Machethe, Professor of Agricultural Economics, University of Pretoria

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Activist Lawyers sue AGF, RMAFC, 15 State Govts, others over Local Govt Transition Committees

law and justiceA group of Activist lawyers under the auspices of Public Interest Lawyers’ Forum have dragged the Attorney General of the Federation, Accountant General of the Federation, Revenue Mobilization, Account and Fiscal Commission, RMAFC and 15 State Attorneys-General before the Federal High Court, Abuja over the legality of Local Government Transition Committees.

The lawyers who filed the suit on behalf of the forum include; former 2nd Vice President of the Nigerian Bar Association, NBA, Monday Ubani, National Publicity Secretary of NBA, Kunle Edun, former Chairman of the NBA Warri branch, John Aikpokpo-Martins, Anne Agi and Emmanuel Ewere.

Defendants in the suit include; Attorneys-Generals of Oyo State, Kogi, Abia, Ondo, Anambra, Imo, Benue, Cross River, Ogun, Borno, Yobe, Kwara, Bauchi, Taraba and Enugu States.

Others are Inspector General of Police, Nigerian Financial Intelligence Unit (NFIU), Federal Minister, Minister of Finance, and Accountant General of the Federation.

The plaintiffs are seeking the court’s determination of the constitutionality/validity of the removal of democratically elected Local Government Chairmen and Councilors and their replacement with Local Government Caretaker or Transitional Committees by State Governments.

Part of their reliefs include; A declaration that the provisions of sections 1(1), 7(1) and 15 (5)of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999, as amended, Cap C23, LFN, 2010 guarantee the tenures of democratically elected Chairmen and Councilors of Local Governments in Nigeria and therefore, supersede the provisions of any law or resolution passed by any State House of Assembly regarding the removal and/or suspension of democratically elected Chairmen and Councilors of Local Governments in Nigeria.

“A declaration that the removal and/or suspension from office of the democratically elected Chairmen and Councilors of the Local Governments Areas and/or continued retention of caretaker committees in place of democratically elected Chairmen and Councilors of the Local Governments of Oyo State, Kogi State, Abia, Ondo, Anambra, Imo , Benue, Cross River, Ogun, Borno , Yobe, Kwara, Bauchi, Taraba and Enugu State by the Governors and the Houses of Assembly of the said States is in violent breach of the extant provisions of sections 1(1), 7(1) and 15 (5)of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999, as amended, Cap C23, LFN, 2010.

” A declaration that the 1999 Nigerian Constitution as amended does not recognize the purported entities called Local Government Transitional or Caretaker Committees or any other interim Local Government administration system, and such creations are therefore unconstitutional.

” An order setting aside the purported removal/suspension of the democratically elected Local Government Chairmen and Councilors and/or retention of non democratically elected officials in various LGA in Oyo State, Kogi State, Abia State, Ondo State, Anambra State, Imo State, Benue State, Ogun State, Cross River State Borno State, Yobe State, Kwara State, Bauchi State, Taraba State and Enugu State

“An order directing all State Governors where elections have not taken place before now in the federation which still runs the local government administration transitional or caretaker Committees to conduct elections immediately into their various Local Government Areas in accordance with Section 7 (1) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 as amended Cap C23, LFN, 2010.

” An order directing the Governors of Oyo State, Kogi State, Abia State, Ondo State, Anambra State, Imo State, Benue State, Ogun State, Cross River State, Borno State, Yobe State, Kwara State, Bauchi State, Taraba State and Enugu State to recover/refund back to the States’ Treasury all funds, remunerations and benefits already paid to members of the said Committees.

” An order directing the 17th, 20th and 21st Defendants not to release any monthly allocation subsequently to any local government administration in any of the states of the federation that is not under a democratically elected government in accordance with Section 7 (1) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 as amended Cap C23, LFN, 2010.”

The Originating Summons was settled by Femi Falana SAN, Ebun-Olu Adegboruwa SAN, Desmond Yamah, Esq and Ikhida Ehighelua, Esq.

The Originating process shows that Affidavit of Non-Multiplicity of action required by the new Federal High Court Rules has been filed. It was deposed to by one Martha C. Eze, a counsel in the law firm of Messrs U. M. Yamah & Co. assuring the court that Plaintiffs have not filed suit elsewhere on the same facts.

Neither date nor any judge has been assigned to the new public interest case.

Destroying Nigeria’s riverside forests is bad for the freshwater ecosystem

Riverside forests are important for freshwater ecosystem
mtcurado/Getty Images

Emmanuel O. Akindele, Obafemi Awolowo University

Nigeria’s population growth – at a rate of more than 2.5% a year – is indirectly driving all kinds of environmental degradation. There is an incessant demand for more space for people to live in and use. One of the consequences is the destruction of forests. Forests that are close to water, known as riparian forests, tend to be most vulnerable.

Access to a watercourse has often informed the choice of human settlement or activity. Needing a year-long supply of water for their crops, farmers often convert riparian forests to agricultural lands. In many cases, especially in the dry season, such farmlands encroach almost into the waterways.

Other kinds of business also need a source of water. In Nigeria, car-wash centres are often sited along rivers and streams where forests once existed. Block-making operations, too, are often situated close to waterways.

The rapid decline in freshwater biodiversity has been attributed to deforestation of riparian corridors and human activities where there were once forests.

This is because riparian forests are the link between aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems.

Riparian forests provide a wide range of ecosystem services and confer a great advantage on their adjacent surface freshwater. They reduce climate change impacts by absorbing carbon dioxide, regulating the micro-climate and providing cover for aquatic ecosystems. They also stabilise river banks, control erosion and siltation of inland waters, and provide food for aquatic animals.

My research group recently investigated a Nigerian stream, Opa Stream, Ile-Ife, whose riparian corridor had been deforested. We found a worrying level of heavy metal pollution in the water. This is probably the result of human activities and related to the loss of forest.

Effects of deforestation

The deforestation of riparian corridor comes with two major impacts. First is the loss of ecosystem services, which leads to the poor health of adjacent freshwater ecosystems. Second is the negative impact on freshwater systems of human activities that take place on land converted from forest. Vegetation would mitigate heavy metal pollution because its presence means no agricultural or industrial activity on the riparian corridor. It also reduces the amount of run-off into freshwater systems, thus reducing the amount of human-generated pollutants.

A most noticeable impact is the release of persistent bio-accumulative toxicants to adjacent waters. These toxicants include heavy metals and organo-metal compounds, which accumulate in animal tissues at higher concentrations along the food chain.

My research group found five heavy metals – lead, cadmium, iron, arsenic and copper – exceeding their freshwater recommended limits in the stream we studied. We also found a strong linkage for concentrations of lead, copper and arsenic between the water column and the stream bed. This suggests that the entire freshwater system was contaminated with the metals and all the resident organisms were predisposed to contamination on account of the metals.

In this case, the heavy metal concentration is due to car-wash activities and block-making industries on the riparian corridor.

The use of pesticides on subsistence and commercial farms too contributed. Cadmium concentration was particularly high in water and sediment samples. High concentration of cadmium is another consequence of agricultural practice on the riparian corridor and it has varied level of toxicity among aquatic animals.

We do not have baseline data on this, but concentrations of these metals could have been heightened by prevalent activities on the riparian corridor.

We reported that a good number of the animals in the stream could be under stress because of the heavy metal pollution. These include the micro-organisms, plankton, insects and fishes, all of which can become less physiologically fit because of heavy metal pollution. Plankton for instance can take up heavy metals in the water column, transfer such to bigger animals in the food chain where they become magnified in concentrations.

Restoring degraded tropical freshwater systems

It’s important to conserve pristine or near-pristine tropical freshwater systems and restore the degraded ones. A good way to start would be by conserving or restoring the health of riparian forests, since this often determines the health of their adjacent water-bodies.

Riparian forests are an inseparable part of freshwater ecosystems, and should be protected by relevant government authorities at local, state and national levels.

People often think about what they can get from nature. They think of food, water, shelter and economic gain – but they don’t always think of the many ecosystem services they get that are less obvious. Human existence hinges on the visible and hidden ecosystem services of nature, including riparian forest and freshwater ecosystems.

This is why individuals, local communities and governments should do more to check the rate of human encroachment on riparian corridors. More effort is also needed to reclaim and reforest these areas.The Conversation

Emmanuel O. Akindele, Senior Lecturer, Obafemi Awolowo University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

How waste pickers in the global South are being sidelined by new policies

Waste pickers are increasingly taking action to oppose policies that exclude them from their source of livelihood.
Swampa (South African Waste Pickers Association)

Federico Demaria, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona and Marcos Todt, Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Rio Grande do Sul

The world is producing more and more waste, with serious health and environmental consequences. In urban areas, domestic waste is accumulating fast and landfills fill up quickly.

Public authorities are trying to manage this problem in new ways. In the global South these tend to involve private corporations and expensive technology rather than waste pickers. This policy shift towards the privatising of waste management is limiting waste pickers’ access to recyclable materials.

This is happening despite the fact that waste pickers are responsible for a very high percentage of recycling. By collecting, sorting and selling discarded materials waste pickers deal with between 20% and 50% of the overall generated waste.

Sidelining waste pickers is leading to conflicts, which a group of researchers and activists are tracking. The Barcelona Research Group on Informal Recyclers – in collaboration with EnvJustice, the Global Alliance of Waste Pickers and Women in Informal Employment: Globalizing and Organizing (WIEGO) – has released a map showing conflicts related to informal recyclers.

The map is a selection from the Environmental Justice Atlas of 50 conflicts in Africa, Asia and Latin America in which waste pickers are fighting for social and environmental justice. The map makes it easy to see who loses and who benefits from policy shifts.

Historically, waste pickers have been confronted with dangerous working conditions, social marginalisation and persecution. The map shows how this precarious situation is getting worse.

Waste, once freely available to the poor, is being appropriated for business purposes. As a result, private corporations obtain large profits, while waste pickers loose their livelihood.

Meanwhile society at large looses the environmental benefits of recycling.

The business of waste

The informal recycling sector is a way of making a living for 19 million to 24 million people in the global South, according to the International Labour Organisation. Their skills and knowledge about materials such as metals, plastics and paper enables them to give items a value.

They provide services to society free of cost, but their work and rights are not always fully recognised. In some countries, such as Brazil and Colombia they are strongly organised in cooperatives and associations. This enables them to voice their claims and even formally take up municipal waste services.

In the past decade, threats to waste picker livelihoods in the global South have been triggered by shifts in public policy towards privatised formal management of urban waste. This has taken three main forms: incineration, privatisation and urban space restrictions.

Incineration: these technologies get large public subsidies, for example as emissions reduction projects from the Clean Development Mechanism of the Kyoto Protocol. The first incinerator in Africa was built in Ethiopia in 2018 with Chinese investment and Danish technology. National bans on incineration are being challenged from the Philippines to Mexico.

Protest Against Incinerators in Quezon City.
Quezon City Case

But research shows that recycling is always preferable to burning. This is true both socially in terms of the livelihoods of waste pickers as well as environmentally for Co2 emissions and risks of air pollution.

In Delhi waste pickers and residents have allied against incineration.

Privatisation: corporations have become increasingly interested in waste as a resource. For example in Johannesburg, the Genesis landfill was privatised and waste pickers got violently evicted. Formal criteria for contracting municipal waste management services that are being put in place end up excluding waste pickers, for example in Egypt and Ghana.

The closure of problematic landfills has often led to the simple shifting of environmental damage in places like Belém and Rio de Janeiro as well.

Protest against waste privatization in Belém.
Belém Case

Restrictions in urban space: these can affect waste pickers, and their livelihoods. An example is the prohibition of animal or human-drawn vehicles. Such examples can be seen in Porto Alegre and Montevideo.

Another example is the installation of “anti-poor”, “smart” containers in Buenos Aires and Bogota.

And, in the name of modern, beautiful and hygienic city centres, waste pickers are denied access to certain urban areas, like in Phnom Penh.

Resistance and mobilisation

Waste pickers are increasingly taking action to oppose policies that exclude them from their source of livelihood. The main areas of focus are social rights and formal inclusion into municipal waste management. They also organise to make their environmental services visible, fight discrimination and empower their communities. This is happening mostly in Latin American countries. But it’s also happening in South Africa and India, among others.

The Global Alliance of Waste Pickers, supported by the nongovernmental organisation Women in Informal Employment: Globalizing and Organizing, works with organisations in more than 28 countries. Their aim is to include waste pickers in decision-making, improve their working conditions, develop their capacity and achieve recognition for their work. Civil society groups have also formed a network in the Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives.

Recognition of the contribution that waste pickers make is growing in some countries. But most still face social marginalisation, highly unsuitable working and living conditions, and most recently a global trend of privatisation of waste management that threatens to deprive them completely of their livelihood.

This article has been written by Nina Clausager, Max Stoisser, Federico Demaria and Marcos Todt. They compose the Barcelona Research Group on Informal Recyclers at ICTA-UAB, together with Valeria Calvas, Rickie Cleere and Chandni Dwarkasing, with the support of Lucía Fernández Gabard and Federico Parra (WIEGO-GlobalRec).The Conversation

Federico Demaria, Researcher in ecological economics and political ecology at the Institute of Environmental Science and Technology, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona and Marcos Todt, Visiting Researcher at the Institute of Environmental Science and Technology (ICTA-UAB) and PhD student in Social Sciences at PUCRS, Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Rio Grande do Sul

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The best time to harvest yams? Science says when the lower leaves turn yellow

A vendor holds a tuber of yam for sale at the popular Mile 12 market in Lagos.
Pius Utomi Ekpei/AFP via Getty Images

Bolanle Akinwande, Ladoke Akintola University of Technology, Ogbomoso

Nigeria accounts for 60% of the world’s [yam output] and 74% of the total production in West Africa. Grown as a staple food, the tuber of the yam plant is its economically important part. The yam tuber, as in other tuber crops, is essentially a starchy or carbohydrate food and its principal nutritional function is the supply of calories.

The challenge, however, is that the onset of maturity in yam is not well understood and the date of harvest often bears no relationship to the functions and activities of the tuber. As a result farmers aren’t able to accurately determine the best time to harvest the crop.

In the course of my research, I have found a scientific process that would enable yam farmers to determine the earliest possible time at which harvesting could be done. I found that the most advantageous time to harvest is when the starch content of the leaf is at minimum levels. It’s as this point that the lower leaves start to turn yellow. I established that this happened before the whole leaves started to decompose, some six months after planting had been done in the rainy season.

Harvesting yams at this point would have two major benefits. It would help improve the food and storage quality of the yam. It would also ensure that the farmer could use the same plot of land for planting another crop, especially vegetables, before the end of the rainy season to generate more income. This would benefit subsistence farmers enormously.

The process

My research involved planting whole seed tubers of various sizes (100 g – 300 g) from five local varieties and 15 genotypes of white yam at the beginning of the rainy season. I conducted my research in 2003 and 2004 but the findings remain relevant.

Harvesting was done at monthly intervals four months after planting was done and when the vines began to emerge. Harvesting continued until the point at which the foliage started to decompose.

Within this period the dry matter, sugar and starch contents of both the leaves and yam tubers were measured. The aim was to derive an indication of the best time to harvest the tuber.

Dry matter: In the leaves dry matter content increased steadily from four months till six months after planting when the lower leaves started to turn yellow. In the tuber dry matter content increased steadily as they aged until all the leaves decomposed. I deduced from this that harvesting was best done when the spike in dry matter content of leaves was noticed – that is when they started to turn yellow.

Sugar content: In the leaves sugar content went up and down as the plants grew, but dropped drastically by the time all the leaves had decomposed. In the tuber, the sugar content reduced as the tuber grew, but then increased sharply by the time the leaves decomposed. My conclusion from this was that it is better to harvest the tubers when there is a sharp decrease in sugar content of leaves – and increase in the sugar content of the tuber.

Starch content: The accumulation of starch in the tuber reached its peak when accumulation of starch in the leaves started which made them turn yellow.

Since yam tuber is essentially a starchy food and its principal nutritional function is the supply of calories, it is most appropriate to harvest it at this time, especially with no appreciable increase in tuber yield any longer.

I concluded from my research that the starch content of leaves was the determining factor for when the tuber had reached maturity. The yam tuber was fully matured when minimum starch content was obtained in the leaves. These low levels of starch content were marked by the yellowing of the lower leaves of the plant. This provided a clear indication of the earliest possible time to harvest the yam.

Tubers of yam on display for sale at the popular Mile 12 market in Lagos.
Pius Utomi Ekpei/AFP via Getty Images

The problem

Before our findings, farmers used subjective ways of determining when to harvest their yams. This often adversely affected the quality and yield of their farms. The most common measures farmers used were observing their yams, as well as calculating when to harvest based on the date of planting.

These rather crude indices had been developed over the years. They were based on observations of the ageing process of parts of the yam, percentage of the tuber length that was whitish at harvest or those that had a bitter taste after cooking.

Using these methods meant that more emphasis was placed on an individual element, such as the taste after cooking. But this amounted to what I call a “maturity of convenience”, rather than “harvest maturity.” And it’s generally a compromise between social requirements and those of the plant’s biology.

The result is that yam tubers are harvested either too early, or too late.

By using the simple technique of harvesting when the lower leaves begin to turn to yellow, farmers can harvest before the entire leaves decompose and be sure of matured yams being harvested. It will also mean that farmers will be able to use the fields to plant for income-earning crops such as vegetables before the end of the farming season. This could translate into improved livelihoods for farmers.The Conversation

Bolanle Akinwande, Professor of Food Science, Ladoke Akintola University of Technology, Ogbomoso

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Lessons from Rwanda on tackling unsafe drinking water and household air pollution

Tubeho Neza community distributions of household water filters and cookstoves in western Rwanda in 2014.
Evan Thomas

Evan Thomas, University of Colorado Boulder; Jean De Dieu Ngirabega, Ruli Higher Institute of Health, and Thomas Clasen, Emory University

Unsafe drinking water and household air pollution are major causes of illness and death around the world. This is also the case in Rwanda, where most people living in rural areas drink untreated water and burn firewood on open stoves to cook their meals. More than 80% of Rwandans rely on firewood as their primary fuel source.

After neonatal disorders, pneumonia and diarrhoeal disease are the two leading killers of children under five years of age in Rwanda. Unsafe drinking water is the leading cause of diarrhoeal disease. And cooking indoors on open-fire stoves, with fuel such as wood and charcoal, has been linked to pneumonia, low birth weight and impaired development in children.

There have been many efforts to address these environmental health issues, but they often lack the financial support to be sustained in the long term.

In 2011, we came together as government, implementers and independent evaluators to design and study a programme that would address these environmental health challenges in Rwanda. It would need to be both sustainable and scalable.

The programme was financed and led by DelAgua, a UK-based water test kit company, in partnership with the Rwanda Ministry of Health. It was branded “Tubeho Neza”, which translates to “live well” in Kinyarwanda an official language of Rwanda.

DelAgua and the Ministry of Health evaluated which technologies could most effectively reduce drinking water contamination and indoor air pollution. They needed to be technologies that people would adopt, were durable, and could be maintained easily by community health workers.

To become financially sustainable, we wanted the project to be eligible for carbon credits under the United Nations Clean Development Mechanism. By reducing wood fuel demands, the project could earn revenue through the generation and sale of these carbon credits.

DelAgua and the Ministry of Health, after certification by the Rwanda Bureau of Standards, decided to use the Vestergaard Frandsen LifeStraw Family 2.0 household water filter and the EcoZoom Dura portable wood-burning cookstove.

A 2012 pilot demonstrated the viability and impact of this programme: households started, and continued, to use the water filters and cookstoves. These findings led to a larger roll-out which started in 2014.

The roll-out

Working with the Rwanda National Police and the Ministry of Health, DelAgua reached over 101,000 households with the water filters and cookstoves. In 2015 they distributed an additional 250,000 cookstoves to nearly a million more people.

Community health workers advised communities and households about proper use of the products. They then visited each household regularly for a year after the distribution to encourage adoption and perform any repairs that were needed.

From 2012 to 2016, the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine and Emory University evaluated the programme. They looked at the design, adoption rate and impacts on water quality, air quality, respiratory disease and diarrhoea, as well as the carbon credit financing mechanism.

This project study was published in 2019 and showed promising results. Among children under five years of age, the intervention reduced seven-day prevalence of reported diarrhoea by 29% and acute respiratory infection by 25%.

As expected, drinking water quality improved, probably explaining the impact on diarrhoea. But people’s exposure to fine particulate matter in the air (measured with personal exposure sensors) remained unchanged, despite increased outdoor cooking with the improved cookstoves. This is consistent with other research that found no protective effect from cooking on improved biomass stoves, such as the Tubeho Neza.

But the study also found that people used the products less over time, as reinforcement by the community health workers became less frequent. As correct, consistent use is essential for achieving health benefits, it is unclear whether the protective effects can be sustained in the absence of regular visits and engagement with households.

Beyond the directly measured health impacts, the people who implement the products also analysed the overall programme costs and benefits. There were savings in fuelwood – an estimated 65,000 tons, enough to reverse deforestation in the region for a few years. Over five years the total programme cost was nearly US$12 million and the total benefit was estimated at over $66 million.

These results suggest that the programme was cost-effective in reducing wood fuel use, improving drinking water quality, and reducing risk of diarrhoea and respiratory illness among children under five.

Future challenges

As long as these products are still in use, DelAgua earns carbon credits which are then sold to the World Bank and other buyers. The aim to is to benefit private sector investors and to support the programme’s continuation.

The water filters and stoves used in the trial are nearing the end of their lifetimes and it does not look as if they can be replaced, given the weak carbon credit market. As a result, DelAgua has transitioned to a focus on carbon-credit subsidised retail sales of these products in Rwanda.

Over the same years as this programme in Rwanda, there were several other large-scale trials of water, sanitation and hygiene interventions in low-income settings. They indicated little or no impacts on health. Similarly, a study of community hygiene clubs in Rwanda – designed to improve awareness without providing any products – showed no impact on health.

Cleaner fuels, such as liquefied petroleum gas, may offer a potential solution to further improving air quality, and are being evaluated in a multi-country trial that includes Rwanda. But accessibility and affordability of such fuels will continue to be a challenge in many settings.

In contrast, the Tubeho Neza programme has showed that it is possible to provide interventions against major diseases to vulnerable households at scale and to secure their adoption and consistent use. It also demonstrated the efficiency of combining critical environmental interventions at the household level. This achievement can inform other national efforts.

Evan Thomas led a team in design and implementation of the programme, Jean de Dieu Ngirabega represented the Ministry of Health, while Thomas Clasen’s team independently studied its impacts.The Conversation

Evan Thomas, Associate Professor, University of Colorado Boulder; Jean De Dieu Ngirabega, Visiting lecturer, Research and Community Health, Ruli Higher Institute of Health, and Thomas Clasen, Professor, Emory University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

AfDB earmarks $500m for 4 agro zones in Nigeria

The African Development Bank (AfDB), yesterday, said it has earmarked $500 million loan for the development of four agro-industrial zones across various states of the Federation. AfDB which made the revelation when it paid a courtesy visit on Clifford Ordia-led Senate Committee on Local and Foreign Debt, said other development partners have also pledged their support.

President of the bank, Akinwumi Adesina, who was represented by his senior special adviser on Industrialisation, Professor Oyebanji Oyelaran-Oyeyinka, said discussions with the Federal Government started since April, 2019.

Called Special Agro Industrial Process, he said it will be similar to the free trade zone, where thousands of direct and indirect jobs will be created for Nigerians across the country. He said: “We have been engaged with the Federal Government since April last year. One of the standout issues in the discussion is the issue of agriculture. There something called Special Agro Industrial Process. It’s similar to the free trade zone. We are in 15 different countries.

“The idea of the zone is for dedicated agribusiness. Africa is lagging behind. Farmers work hard, but they get very little. When the President of the bank was the Minister of Agriculture, he started about 14 of these zones. A lot was spent. Since he left as Minister, nothing has happened since then. “The bank has advanced $500 million to beef up these zones in the next few years. The private sector and others are pledging support. These funds will be used to provide roads and other infrastructure.

“We are tired of people laughing at us in Nigeria. This project is working in other countries. It can also work here. The AfDB is there to support Nigeria.

“Our goal is that, in the next two years, we will begin to see results. Every state will be affected. Nigeria shouldn’t be importing food. We should be at the forefront of exporting food to other parts of the world.

Speaking on behalf of other senators, chairman of the Committee, Ordia, pledged the support of the upper legislative chamber.

He urged the continental bank to carry every stakeholder along, while decrying the late briefing of lawmakers.

NEXIM bank to promote sesame seeds processing for export in Katsina

The Nigerian Export-Import Bank (NEXIM) says it has concluded plans to promote crops that have potential export value in Katsina State thereby creating more businesses and job opportunities for people.

The Managing-Director, NEXIM Bank, Mr Abba Bello, disclosed this when Gov. Aminu Masari of Katsina State visited him on Wednesday in Abuja.

Bello said that the initiative would significantly create a lot of job opportunities in the state.

According to him, the bank will be working with some potential exporters from Katsina State to ensure proper implementation of the processes.

“One of the reasons we chose to work with states is that we prefer to go down to the grassroots that is financing them from primary production to aggregation and finally export and we have been working on the process.

“We have identified the crops to process and export in Katsina State precisely sesame seeds and also to some extent hibiscus.

“Also, a cooperation has been signed between a group and a proposed aggregator who already have 1,800 hectares of land and signed up over 1,000 farmers that will process this season of sesame from Katsina State and we hope to see to the conclusion,” he said

The managing-director also said that the bank, having started working on the value chain, would identify a few Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) that buy sesame seeds and supply.

“We have a programme which is in line with the Federal Government determination to bring people out of poverty.

“This is the reason why we have decided to go down the value chain and finance both micro and small enterprises that are in the value chain for export.

“Some have already started utilising our facilities and we are looking to do more in Katsina State,” he said.

He was also hopeful that the initiative would further support the economic empowerment in the state and the Federal Government Economic Recovery and Growth Plan, particularly with emphasis on bringing people out of poverty.

“So we will ensure that our funding gets to the very base of the value chain,” Bello added.

Masari, while speaking commended the management of the bank for identifying an export crops in the state, saying that “the state is developing 800 hectares of land for economic export.”

According to him, the government of Katsina State has already given a contract for the complete development of a 100 hectares.

“So part of what we are looking for here is processing and adding value, especially to agric products and other exportable products to the neighbouring countries.

News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that NEXIM bank has mapped out N1 billion each to support non oil export products across the 36 states and the Federal Capital Territory (FCT)

NAN

Uganda offers lessons in tapping the power of solid waste

Solid waste in Mulago, Kampala, 2010. The city’s residents have found ways to recycle waste into energy.
SuSanA Secretariat/Flickr, CC BY-SA

Shuaib Lwasa, Makerere University

In places where municipalities continuously fail to collect and manage waste, authorities tend to concentrate their efforts in a few areas. These are often in a city’s wealthier sections. Informal settlements remain under-served or are not served at all. And so, waste accumulates.

Kampala, the capital of Uganda, is home to 1.5 million residents. It is growing at an annual rate of 5.1%. The expansion of cities like Kampala makes service provision difficult; infrastructure is poor and so are the roads that connect its neighbourhoods. About 87% of Kampala’s residents live in informal houses; 78% have access to electricity in their houses and only 17% have piped water. An estimated 1,300 tons per day of waste are produced in the city and about 50% is collected and transported to the landfill.

In this context, the absence of waste management and sanitation has led residents to come up with solutions to make usable products out of organic waste materials. One such innovation is producing energy briquettes from both organic and human wastes, or fecal sludge.

Marketing energy briquettes.
By Shuaib Lwasa

Innovations emerge from the informal sector

Our research show that in cities such as Kampala, many individuals benefit economically from this informal sector, which also improves waste management services and addresses climate change.

Turning waste into a reliable source of energy is not new. Examples can be found in India, Bangladesh, Bolivia and many others. The waste-to-energy method is designed primarily as climate change mitigation to reduce emissions. But it also has huge potential to address employment problems.

Turning organic waste into energy in Nepal.

This type of economic activity is not part of the official urban economic sector, yet it can greatly contribute to the economy. It requires innovation, community and business involvement and support from researchers. A small briquette-making business with semi-mechanised moulding machines would require an estimated 15 million UGX (about 3,700 euros) to capitalise.

In Kampala, we observed how this business model is being used to promote waste-to-energy in impoverished neighbourhoods to create jobs and expanded economic opportunities.

Tapping a free resource

Making energy briquettes from organic wastes is not new; this has been in production since the 1980s in Kampala. But there’s room for even more growth if businesses of this nature can grow to medium size. This can help in recovering uncollected waste materials from other neighbourhoods.

In Kampala, organic materials thrown away by residents include food waste, plant leaves and stems, fecal sludge. This material is collected by the groups, dried to reduce water, crushed and made into a char. The char is then mixed with a binder such as sawdust, dirt or clay with a little water and fed into a moulding machine that produces briquettes of different sizes and types. The briquettes are then dried to reduce the moisture and packed for sale.

Seasoning energy briquettes.
Shuaib Lwasa

Organic solid wastes produce greenhouse gasses when they decompose. So businesses that reduce the amount of waste going to landfills can cumulatively reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

Booming “waste” labs in the slums

We worked with NGOs such as ACTogether (affiliated to Slum Dwellers International) to identify informal settlements for piloting the businesses. We conducted a baseline study on the nature and quantities of organic waste, flows, waste types and major sources in the neighbourhoods. This was followed by consultations with 10 community producing groups with an average of 15 members, both men and women, about the possibilities of scaling up the energy-briquette businesses.

We organised several meetings and training workshops covering topics of energy-briquette product development, business-plan development, branding and marketing as well as skills in bookkeeping and accounting. Community groups are at different levels in briquette making. Some were experienced and producing as much as one ton per week, while others were just starting out.

The different community producing groups will be seeded for capital acquisition of fabricating machines, carbonising stoves, crushers and seasoning racks. Established groups, meanwhile, will require solar dryers, product branding and marketing drives.

The producing groups have established laboratories in the slums to test the different ingredients before rolling the products out for sale. And one of the key sales pitches is the emissions reduction of the briquettes compared to charcoal.

A strong organisation

There are also some groups that collect and deliver the organic wastes to the fabricating groups. Some take it further, producing char that they sell to the groups that make briquettes. These back-end businesses are evolving, including hiring youths to collect organic wastes and transporting them to the production units. Front-end businesses involving community members and youth groups are also emerging, specialisation in producing char that’s sold to fabricators.

Briquette machine.
Shuaib Lwasa, Author provided

The community groups are establishing cooperatives for collective marketing of the briquettes. The cooperatives are working on quality control and standardisation since the groups produce briquettes independently.

Briquette quality control involves looking at the ingredients used, the carbonisation, mixing ratios and types of wastes used as a binder. The binder determines the length of time that a briquette will burn and thus its calorific value – that is, the selling quality in comparison to competitor products such as charcoal.

Fecal sludge can provide jobs

More than 75% of the households in Kampala use pit latrines and only 13% are connected to the sewer network. This implies that only a small fraction of human waste is treated. An innovation has evolved where small businesses have been established to collect and transport human waste to treatment plants.

This emerging economic activity is creating jobs, which are growing from a small to medium scale of operation.

Women and youth groups have developed waste-collection businesses that use the gulper technology to empty pit latrines and transport materials to sewerage treatment plants using tricycles with small tanks.

Continuous monitoring of greenhouse gas emissions from production through use by households is important. Our team has established a protocol for tracking emissions through periodic measurement at all the piloting production units during production and a few households who are close by that use the briquettes for cooking.

The branding will also include the information on the greenhouse gas emissions produced when briquettes are burned, and how much is saved to mitigate climate change. The hope using this method is that users will adopt the use of briquette as individual responsibility toward saving the planet from warming further.

Gulper technology to empty latrines.

A reproducible initiative

The amount of greenhouse gases generated by Kampala is negligible, relatively speaking, at an estimated 200g per person and a total of 0.7 million tons of CO2 per year. But producing energy briquettes from solid organic waste is an innovation that can be adopted in other cities that are searching for alternative pathways to sustainability.

We are also working with youth groups that are interested in tapping the energy from fecal sludge by transforming it directly into energy briquettes. This process is still in its infancy compared to briquettes from solid organic waste. But it is worth looking at as we continue exploring pathways to sustainability that are inclusive, resilient and sustainable.


Created in 2007 to help accelerate and share scientific knowledge on key societal issues, the Axa Research Fund has been supporting nearly 600 projects around the world conducted by researchers from 54 countries. To learn more, visit the site of the Axa Research Fund.The Conversation

Shuaib Lwasa, Geographer, Makerere University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

CBN To Offer Single-Digit Loans To Rice Farmers

The Central Bank of Nigeria said it would offer single-digit loan to rice farmers in the Niger Delta area and provide index insurance for participating farmers.

This was contained in a statement signed by the Head, Press and Public Relations at the Ministry of Niger Delta Affairs, Patricia Deworitshe.

It was issued after a second collaborative meeting between the Minister of Niger Delta Affairs, Godswil Akpabio, and representatives of the CBN in Abuja.

The meeting focused on how to develop the Niger Delta area, using farming as a tool on Friday.

According to Deworitshe, the representative of the CBN Governor at the meeting, Mr Anthony Ifechukwu, said that the CBN in 2018 identified cassava, rice, oil palm and cocoa farming as those with comparative advantage in the region, adding that the apex bank was also making effort to intervene in livestock and fishery production in the region.

The statement said, “Ifechukwu also assured participating farmers of a guaranteed market price for their produce, explaining that the bank would give a single-digit interest loan for five years.

“He advised eligible farmers willing to participate in the scheme to procure quality seedlings from reputable companies and plant their crops in clusters, adding that CBN will do index insurance for participating farmers.”

Speaking at the meeting, Akpabio, who was represented by Permanent Secretary at the ministry, Adesola Olusade, reiterated the resolve of the ministry to key into the agricultural revolution in partnership with the CBN.

He said the ministry would focus on land acquisition for the project by approaching governors of the nine states in the region to address the issue (land acquisition) under the Land Use Act.

Akpabio stated that discussion on land acquisition would form part of the agenda for the next national council meeting, which would be held in Rivers State. Punch